Top Restaurants US

10 Best Italian Restaurants in Chicago: Best Picks for 2024

Sahana Ananth
June 21, 2024
1 mins

Table of Content

Chicago, one of the most popular cities in the United States, is well known for its friendly weather and vibrant cuisine. For food lovers, there is an amazing fact about this city: Though you are traveling in America, you can still enjoy authentic Italian cuisine. 

If you are visiting or have plans to visit Chicago, don’t miss out on checking out the Italian restaurants. Imagine forkfuls of creamy, rich pasta with red wine. To end the meal beautifully, order a freshly made tiramisu. Sounds mouthwatering? A true Italian food lover can’t deny it.

You will find everything in this state, from cozy bistro to elegant spots. For your convenience, we have listed the best Italian restaurants in Chicago. In addition to detailed restaurant information, we will share tips, pricing ideas, and a proper Google map to save your time. 

Buon appetito!

10 Best Italian Restaurants in Chicago in 2024

1. Daisies

Daisies is located at Logan Square and is famous for its farm-to-table approach. If you are searching for a romantic dinner or a hangout with your loved ones, this spot is divine. The restaurant atmosphere has a modern interior with a rustic touch to provide you with a delightful experience. 

Whether you want an Onion Dip or a Cubano, everything is available gluten-free. The fresh ingredients and local seafood help the restaurant retain customers. 

Another person who deserves to be mentioned is Thomas Leonard, the Head of Culinary at Daisies. He is a total Italian who loves to cook appetizing Italian food and instructs all the staff properly. 

Visitor's Tip

Never miss their seasonal vegetables and seafood items. They are famous for freshly made pasta with luscious secret sauce. Moreover, Daisies has a fine collection of Wine (from 2008 to 2023) with lots of variation. You should try it at least once. 

Pricing

The overall price range is $7-$90. Within this price range, you will get lunch, dinner, drinks, desserts, and wine. The freshness and high quality of the food won’t disappoint your expected Italian culinary experience.

Address: 2375 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60647

Google Map: Daisies Map

Website: https://www.daisieschicago.com/

2. Monteverde

Are you aware of American Happy Hour? Italian people love to have APERITIVO HOUR. During this time, they like chit-chat and relaxing with friends and family. Monteverde has Aperitivo Hour for you with multiple cocktails that are low in alcohol content. If you want to avoid gluten from your plate, you can check their Gluten-Free meals and ask for any further moderation. 

The dessert section contains a tempting MV Pantry Gift containing Chef Sarah's favorite ingredients in each box. Such as, 

  • Citrus Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  • Mieli Thun Honey
  • DeCarlo
  • Acetaia San Giacomo Agro Di Mosto Balsamico
  • A signed copy of the Listen to Your Vegetable Cookbook
  • A Listen to Your Vegetables Tote Bag

Visitor's Tip

If you plan to visit Monteverde, don’t forget to reserve a table as it’s extremely popular. Their Cacio Whey Pepe is a famous dish; don’t leave without trying it. They also serve freshly made Tiramisu; you shouldn’t miss this divine dish. 

Pricing

The pricing range is $4-$1000. If you taste their Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, or Wine you will understand why the price is justified. 

Address: 1020 W Madison St, Chicago, IL 60607

Google Map: Monteverde Map

Website: https://monteverdechicago.com/

3. Sapori Trattoria

You can find this restaurant at Lincoln Park, with the warmth of traditional Italian kitchens. Sapori Trattoria's fresh pasta is the talk of the town now, and people love its authentic flavors. Their classic dishes are served in generous portions, and you will enjoy them in a very homely atmosphere. 

Moreover, Sapori Trattoria offers Catering services for any kind of Italian or customized food you want for your home party. Plus, you can purchase Gift Cards for your loved ones and surprise them. The most innovative part of this restaurant is that they have a Wine club where you can join as a member. We can’t explore more information as it’s private.

Visitor's Tip

Though you can order online from Sapori Trattoria, you should visit their place. In the evening there could be a rush so try to arrive earlier. Their Calamari Fritti is an amazing appetizer, and if you try Parmigiana Trenta, you will fall in love with it. 

Pricing

The price range is typically $7-$65. Their pricing is quite reasonable for a high-quality and satisfying Italian meal. 

Address: 2550 N Lincoln Ave, Chicago, IL 60614

Google Map: Sapori Trattoria Map

Website: https://www.saporitrattoria.net/

4. Volare

Volare was established in 1997 in Chicago and managed by a family. This restaurant gives the vibe of an old-world Italian establishment, and you can explore traditional Italian cuisine here.

From classic comfort dishes to a new era of Italian cooking, you can have them all in Valore. Their interior reflects the authentic Italian world, and you should plan for a date if you are in Chicago. Moreover, family get-togethers or any surprise party can be held here with their succulent dishes. 

Suppose you don’t want to get out of your pajamas and crave an Italian feast- try their online order instantly.

Visitor's Tip

During peak hours, tables are hard to get, so reserve earlier. Their dessert section is minimal, but you will find uncountable options for wine. Their Ravioli di Ricotta and Lasagna al Forno are highly recommended. 

Pricing

Valore’s price range is from $5-$900. The regular dinner items are priced similarly to other Italian restaurants. You have to pay more if you want to taste their limited-edition Wines. 

Address: 201 E Grand Ave, Chicago, IL 60611 (Grand Ave. & St. Clair)

Google Map: Volare Map

Website: https://www.volarerestaurant.com/

5. Ciccio Mio

For a special celebration or romantic date, Ciccio Mio’s dining experience will blow your guests' minds. The whole interior setup reflects royalty, and every decoration is elegant. After entering the restaurant, you will automatically pronounce Mamma Mia! 

You have heard about Online Ordering; in Ciccio Mio, you can Pre-Order Online. They have some traditional and classic Italian dishes cooked for dedicated customers. 

This restaurant is particularly famous for Northern Italian cuisine; the menu features tempting hearty meat, vegetables, creamy pastas, classic desserts, cocktails, and wines. 

Visitor's Tip

Try their menu of the day, specially created by the chef. It offers the best meals of the restaurant. They have a limited seating area, so you had better reserve before arriving there. Ciccio Mio has some unique dessert items; you can also try them. 

Pricing

The price range is around $7-$2000. For $500, you can get an appetizer, dinner, cocktails, and wine. They serve 1998 wine, which costs around $2888.

Address: 226 W Kinzie St, Chicago, IL 60654

Google Map: Ciccio Mio Map

Website: https://cicciomio.com/

6. Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse

This Italian restaurant is named after the famous American Sportscaster Harry Caray. It was established in River North in 1987. His family is continuing the legacy by opening seven restaurants and catering services. They also have the Chicago Sports Museum. 

Smoky barbecue, juicy burgers, sizzling steak, and many more are available, all influenced by Italian unique tastes. The huge interior makes holding a big party or cozy family event easy. 

Hold your breath if you see any big politicians, Hollywood actors, or actresses because everyone loves to visit this place for the tremendous food taste. Their Celebrity Gallery says it all. 

Visitor's Tip

Every visitor loves their Chicago classic with an Italian twist. Prime Steaks & Chops is one of their must-try items. They use the finest Midwestern USDA Prime beef for better tenderness and flavor. They also offer kids' menus under $10.95.

Pricing

The price starts from $2 to $350. They offer affordable dessert wines starting from $20. The dining experience and the food quality will force you to visit again and again. 

Address: 33 W Kinzie St, Chicago, IL 60654

Google Map: Harry Caray's Map

Website: https://www.harrycarays.com/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/harrycarays/

7. La Gondola

La Gondola serves the best homemade Italian food and Chicago-style pizza. Established in 1991, it has won awards for its classic Italian food.

They use fresh ingredients, and the pizza dough is always hand-tossed. That’s why their pizza is famous in Chicago. Among Italian cuisine, La Gondola includes homemade creamy pastas and fresh seafood.

This Italian restaurant is also owned by a family who want to indulge you with food from Venice to Chicago. It’s highly recommended for big family events. 

Visitor's Top

La Gondola serves fresh and flavorful seafood pasta, its house specialty. This restaurant is famous among locals, so it's wise to reserve a table before arriving.

Pricing

Food is reasonably priced between $7 and $150. For plating fresh, good-quality, and generous portions of food at an affordable price, people love to hang out there often. Moreover, their wine prices are suitable for your pocket. 

Address: 2914 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60657

Google Map: La Gondola Map

Website: https://www.lagondolachicago.com/

8. Tortello

Sometimes, sitting inside for dinner can be boring. Tortello has a beautiful outdoor and indoor dining area. Like the restaurant's unique and romantic interior, it has a story behind it. 

Dario Monni was born and raised in Italy. He started learning handmade pasta from his Nonna (grandmother) and the show continues with Tortello. This restaurant is run by Dario and Jill (his future wife, a pure Chicagoan) with a love for Italian cuisine. Every ingredient is fresh and dedicated to creating authentic food every day. 

Their menu is simple yet delectable, highlighting handmade cheese and pasta. From making food for the table to bottled food products, you just named it. Tortello has its own grocery shop where you can find all the items you need to cook Italian cuisine at home. You will find it after scrolling down their menu.

Visitor's Top

Their fresh Fennel, Celery & Orange Salad can be a great appetizer for your table. Start your dinner with Signature Tortelli di Burrata, then finish with their classic Salame al Cioccolato. You will recommend others; we can bet!

Pricing

You can start ordering from $7 to $250. Given their freshness and authenticity, this price is quite surprisingly reasonable. 

Address: 1746 W Division St, Chicago, IL 60622

Google Map: Tortello Map

Website: https://www.tortellopasta.com/

9. Siena Tavern

This is another gem in Chicago with an elegant, vibrant, and royal aura that offers the best Italian food experience. Siena Tavern has an oval-shaped bar at the center that gives a 360-degree view. In the heart of River North, Chicago, you will experience the food love from Italy.

Here, you can host a wedding, corporate event, or big family get-together for 200 people. Most people visit for the scenic night view. 

This classic yet modern restaurant offers many dining options. You can even bring your pets there, as they offer a special pet menu called Puppy Ciao. So, you don’t need to leave them behind at home now.

Visitor's Tip

The Gnocchi and Baked Lasagna are highly recommended for dinner. For dessert, you must try the Chocolate Gianduja Bar. Don’t miss out on their bar section at the end of your meal. Finally, an early reservation can save your day. 

Pricing

Expect to pay between $6 and $800. The most expensive section is actually their Wine section. They have a vast collection to please you. The prices are actually worth every penny. You will agree after having a visit.

Address: 51 W Kinzie St, Chicago, IL 60654

Google Map: Siena Tavern Map

Website: https://www.sienatavern.com/

10. La Scarola

La Scarola is also a family-owned restaurant where you will feel a warm and welcoming atmosphere. You can call it a casual restaurant where Traditional Italian decor and classic food items make it heaven for people who want to have a visit to Italian cuisine. 

Their appetizers, soup, and pasta are popular because they use fresh ingredients. From seafood to authentic spaghetti meatballs, you can have it all. 

This is a crowded place where people are always there for drinks or food. The list of beverage items is not long, but the demand for these drinks is unbelievable. Explore the photo gallery to roam around the place before reserving your table.

Visitor's Tip

The restaurant's setup is perfect for a friend's hangout. But we won't recommend it if you want to go on a serious date. Please note that they don’t have any wine on the list.

Pricing

La Scarola is a locally popular Italian restaurant, and this is only possible because of handy prices, which start from $3, and any food item never exceeds $45. 

Address: 721 West Grand Avenue Chicago, Illinois 60610

Google Map: La Scarola Map

Website: https://lascarola.com/

Final Takeaway on Selecting the Bellissima Restaurant

Chicago is an amazing city because it’s beside the shoreline of Lake Michigan. Getting fresh seafood and other ingredients is super easy in this location, which is why all the best Italian restaurants are in this area. 

We know Italian food is not just about pizza, pasta, or tiramisu; this is an experience that you will remember. After thinking thoughtfully as a food lover, we have listed the best Italian restaurants in Chicago.

Book a table today and enjoy the food with your loved ones. If you have visited any of the listed restaurants, don't hesitate to share your experience. 

Buona Giornata!

How do I figure out how much to charge for food?

Pricing is a balancing act! You need to cover your costs (including the food cost per portion) while offering a price point that feels valuable to your customers. Consider factors like competition, target audience, and the overall dining experience you create.

What tools are available for tracking food costs?

Food cost calculators are great for initial estimates, but consider restaurant management software for ongoing success. This software tracks inventory, automates cost calculations, and generates reports to identify cost-saving opportunities.

Can I use a food cost calculator for different types of cuisine?

Absolutely! Many online food cost calculators can handle various cuisines. Look for tools that consider ingredient types, portion sizes, and even regional pricing variations.

How often should I calculate food cost percentage?

Consider your food cost percentage your restaurant's financial fitness tracker. It's the total cost of recipe ingredients divided by your total menu sales. Ideally, calculate this regularly, like weekly or bi-weekly, to monitor profitability and adjust pricing or portions as needed.

What is the standard costing model?

The standard costing model is like a recipe for consistent pricing. It uses historical data and market trends to predict ingredient costs, allowing you to budget, purchase, and maintain profit margins even when prices fluctuate.

What is food cost per portion?

Food cost per portion is the actual cost of creating a single serving of a dish. It considers all ingredients, including spices, garnishes, and even waste!  This number helps you understand your profitability and set menu prices effectively.

AUTHOR
Sahana Ananth
Director, GTM - OneHubPOS

Sahana is a seasoned GTM leader with a passion for building startups. She excels in crafting GTM strategies for tech products, driving revenue growth.

Read more